Allen, Peter. “Christian Socialism and the
Broad Church Circle,” Dalhousie Review Vol. 49 (Spring, 1969): 58-68.
Allen discusses Kingsley’s involvement in the Christian Socialist movement
of 1848-1854. He argues that most of the Christian Socialists were members
of the Broad Church circle and that political radicalism or political socialism
was far from being their principal concern. Rather, they believed that
moral or educational reform of the working classes must precede political
action, a viewpoint strongly adhered to by Kingsley. Though a minority
of the Christian Socialists, for example J. M. Ludlow, advocated extreme
political reform, Allen suggests that the evidence indicates “that
we cannot understand Christian Socialism and its leaders if we look only
to the history of political radicalism, but that the movement might appear
in a new and valuable light through a thorough study of the Broad Church
circle. Rather than seeing Christian Socialism as primarily a political
movement diverted from its true aims, we should, I think, see it as an outgrowth
of a school of religious thought and of a certain intellectual and social
group in Victorian society” (66-67).
Christian
Socialism ; Religion
; Social
and Political Views .
Baker, William J. “Charles Kingsley on
the Crimean War: A Study In Chauvinism.” Southern Humanities Review
Vol. IV, No. 3 (Summer 1970): 247-256.
Baker notes that the Crimean War was occurring while Kingsley was writing
Westward Ho!, a war to which he refers over and over in this
novel. Numerous aspects of this later war were similar, he believed, in many
respects to the earlier war with Spain. The chauvinism he consistently
displayed during the Crimean War fostered as well as reflected the chauvinism
of his contemporaries. Moreover, Kingsley, who never fought in a war,
had a romantic “boy-like fantasy” view of war (254). While in many ways,
declares Baker, he was liberal, compassionate, a free-thinking cleric, a
supporter of the poor, an advocate for social reform, a critic of the discriminatory
class system, “his liberal sensitivity stopped at the northern edge of the
English Channel”. He combined in a contradictory stance “an insightful
concern for his country's social problems alongside an uncritical bellicosity
toward national foes” (255).
Westward
Ho! ; Crimean War
; War ; Chauvinism
; Social
and Political Views .
Beer, Max. A History of British Socialism
. Vol. II (London: Bell and Sons, 1929).
In his treatment of Christian Socialism Beer declares that Kingsley “thought
the real battle of the time was not Radical or Whig against Peelite or Tory,
but the Church, the gentleman, the workman against the shopkeepers and the
Manchester School” (183).
Christian
Socialism ; Social
and Political Views .
Bodenheimer, Rosemarie. The Politics
of Story in Victorian Social Fiction (Ithaca: Cornell University Press,
1988): 135-150.
Bodenheimer declares that the chaotic nature of Alton Locke is due
to the novel's original composition. It was written during 1849 and
1850 in “unchronological fragments” (135). Kingsley displays an acute
ambivalence throughout the work. His middle class sensibility fired
by class sympathy results in “something like pathology” (137). "Alton Locke
oscillates wildly between its commitment to the circumstances of working-class
life and its yearning for a pastoral world, until it finally collapses into
a dream vision that resolves the conflict by changing the meanings of its
original terms. In the process Kingsley inadvertently deconstructs
the ideological opposition between social conflict and pastoral harmony,
producing versions of pastoral that reveal on the one hand its reliance on
aristocratic society and on the other its evolutionary connection with human
drives to lust and power” (135).
Alton Locke
; Social
and Political Views ; Characterization
in Novels .
Brantlinger, Patrick.
“The Case against Trade Unions in Early Victorian Fiction,” Victorian
Studies Vol. XIII, No. 1 (September 1969): 37-52.
Kingsley’s reaction to the Preston Strike of 1853-54 and his views in Alton
Locke, according to Brantlinger, reveal his hostility to strikes and
trade unions. The primary problem with trade unions for Kingsley is
that “they are competitive rather than cooperative associations” (47).
Alton Locke
; Social
and Political Views ; Trade Unions
.
Brantlinger, Patrick. The Reading Lesson:
The Threat of Mass Literacy in Nineteenth-Century British Fiction (Bloomington
and Indianapolis: Indiana University Press, 1998).
Brantlinger stresses that throughout Alton Locke Kingsley, though recognizing
that the working classes are more and more literate, considers that they
are not yet adequately advanced to best represent their own interests. Literacy
was not in itself sufficient to cure the social anarchy of the masses.
Alton
Locke ; Social
and Political Views ; Literacy.
Brewer, Elizabeth.
“Morris and the ‘Kingsley Movement',” The Journal of the William Morris
Society Vol. IV, No. 2 (Summer 1980): 4-17.
Brewer examines the possible influence Kingsley’s works may have had on Morris.
She believes that it is very difficult to specify categorically that there
was a direct influence, though there are many instances where the thought
of both men overlapped. She discusses, among others, the attack on celibacy
and asceticism in The Saint’s Tragedy and Hypatia; Kingsley’s
stress on the importance of the environment in Yeast; the socio-political
ideas pervading Alton Locke ; Kingsley’s belief in the value of art,
an awareness of one's heritage, and the pleasures of rural life to the ordinary
working man; the use of the dream device in Alton Locke; the romance
as well as the Norse element of Hypatia.
Morris,
William ; Saint’s
Tragedy, The ; Hypatia ;
Alton
Locke ; Westward
Ho! ; Yeast ; Celibacy
; Social
and Political Views .
Brinton, Crane. English Political Thought
in the Nineteenth Century (Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 1954;
first published 1933).
Brinton provides an overview of Kingsley’s life and his major social and
political views. While his Christian Socialism was by no means a system,
Kingsley held that a Christian Socialist society would indeed be hierarchical
where each one's place is determined by his moral value as well as democratic
in the sense that each one's place has been allotted by God. Brinton
considers that Kingsley’s ideal society was based on older English societies
where different social classes “were knit together by habits which were genuine
human relationships”. His “programme is singularly like
that of Tory Democracy” (125). Kingsley’s paternalism did not signify
that he rejected competition. Competition was good but workers must
first be members of cooperative associations, an ideal similar to “modern
guild Socialism” (126). While Brinton considers that Kingsley’s achievements
were not insignificant, his ideals based on his religious faith could accomplish
little to improve the very practical ills of working class and under-privileged
society. “His God, his virtue, his England, made too many promises
to the flesh – promises unfulfilled to the common man. For the uncommon
man, his faith was even more inadequate. Taste and intellect alike
recoil from the simplicities of a universe on the pattern of Eversley” (130).
Social
and Political Views ; Alton Locke
; Christian
Socialism ; Religion
; Science
; Evolution
; Democracy
; Capitalism
; Teutons
.
Brunskill, F. R.
“Charles Kingsley's Social Philosophy,” Primitive Methodist Quarterly
Review Vol. 25 (April 1903): 340-349.
Brunskill gives an ornate account of Kingsley’s work on behalf of the poor
and less privileged and discusses his social and political views.
Social
and Political Views ; Social and
Political Novel .
Byrom, Thomas. “Introduction”
to Charles Kingsley, Alton Locke: Tailor and Poet (London: Dent 1970):
v-xi.
Byrom considers Alton Locke to be an ambiguous and confusing novel.
Kingsley is ambivalent about violence. While he clearly sides with
Alton and the notion of a fighting working class, he also agrees with the
orderly and conservative ideals of an aristocracy enlightened by the Church.
Kingsley is surprising in leaving Catholicism relatively untouched; rather
it is the dissenters, especially the Baptists, who receive a harsh criticism.
Also, the Tractarians are criticized as is Transcendentalism which Bryom
considers Kingsley failed to understand properly. Unlike Yeast
which suffered from an excessive authorial presence, the autobiographical
mode of Alton Locke results in a work more a novel than a tract.
Bryom concludes that Alton Locke, though entertaining, “is only a
fitful success. Reading it is rather like watching a film in which much
of the footage is out of focus” (ix). Though it is primarily to be
considered a failure when compared to the works of Dickens, this is instructive.
“Alton Locke was written when English fiction enjoyed its greatest
moment, and without it we should have a harder time understanding the achievement
of Dickens, who in so many respects shared the conservative, reforming, doubting,
bitter, compassionate sensibility of the stuttering Rector of Eversley” (x).
Alton Locke
; Dissent
; Transcendentalism
; Dickens
; Social
and Political Views .
Cazamian, Louis. The Social Novel in
England 1830-1850: Dickens, Disraeli, Mrs. Gaskell, Kingsley Trans. Martin
Fido (London: Routledge and Kegan Paul, 1973; first published in French in
1903).
Cazamian provides a lengthy examination of Kingsley's life and works, focusing
on his Christian Socialist activities and, particularly, on how Christian
Socialism is represented in his novels, Yeast and Alton Locke
. Cazamian considers Kingsley a "gifted writer" who employs these novels
as a "propaganda vehicle" to describe the age's "most vital aims and ideals"
(241).
Overview
; Social
and Political Views ; Christian
Socialism ; Alton Locke
; Yeast ;
Novels
.
Chadwick, Owen. "Charles Kingsley at Cambridge,"
The Historical Journal Vol. XVIII, No. 2 (1975): 303-325.
Chadwick examines Kingsley’s time at Cambridge both as an undergraduate and
as the Regius Chair of Modern History. In addition to considering the
circumstances of his election as Professor and the reactions of University
personnel and the wider community, Chadwick discusses such topics as his pedagogical
abilities, the responses of the students, the content of his lectures, and
his philosophy of history. Chadwick also intersperses accounts of many
of Kingsley’s views on, for example, Catholicism, Newman, science, evolution,
sanitation, sexuality, muscular Christianity, together with brief treatments
of some of his novels. He concludes: “But unsophisticated, no; natural,
only when he intended naturalness; innocent, not merely no but quite
the opposite – who would have thought the good man to have so much blood
in his fancy? If you go along with Kingsley until you begin to know
him, you wonder whether this unsubtle man was not one of the most complicated
souls you ever met” (325).
Overview
; Cambridge
University ; History
Professor ; History ;
Social
and Political Views .
Chitty, Susan. The Beast and the Monk:
A Life of Charles Kingsley (New York: Mason/Charter, 1974).
For this excellent book-length biography of Kingsley Chitty had access to
three hundred love letters from Kingsley to Fanny that had hithertoo not
been viewed by anyone outside the family, as well as to a locked diary kept
by Fanny in Nice during her year's separation from Kingsley in 1843.
The latter contained some revealing, sexually charged drawings. Chitty
declares that it is because of these new sources "that the present biography
can claim to give a fuller and more intimate picture of Kingsley than any
that has till now appeared" (17).
Full Book Treatment
; Overview
; Sexuality
; Social
and Political Views .
Christensen, Allan C. “Sick Mothers and
Daughters: Symptoms of Cultural Disorder in Novels by Manzoni, Dickens, Kingsley,
Bulwer-Lytton, James,” RSV: Rivista di Studi Vittoriani Vol. 7, No.
4 (January 1999): 5-32.
Christensen discusses the relationship of mother and daughter in Two Years
Ago in the context of society's "sick cultural system" (6).
“The passionate reunification of mother and daughter thus comes to typify
not only the event that will restore health to a particular plague-stricken
culture but also the redemption of the human race” (26).
Two Years
Ago ; Mothers and
Daughters ; Females ;
Social
and Political Views .
Colloms, Brenda. “Charles Kingsley, Poet and
Social Reformer,” RSV: Rivista di Studi Vittoriani Vol. 1, No. 2 (July
1996): 23-47.
In a lengthy article Colloms provides a sketch of Kingsley’s life, character,
and works, concentrating on his poetry. She praises in particular the
“disturbing and powerful” poem “St. Maura” but declares that Kingsley will
be remembered by the general public for his shorter poems (36). She
also lauds Kingsley for having added the topic of social problems to the
scope of the popular novel.
Overview
; Poetry
; Social
and Political Views .
Cripps, Elizabeth A. "Introduction," Alton
Locke, Tailor and Poet: An Autobiography (Oxford; New York: Oxford University
Press, 1983): vii-xx.
Cripps introduces Alton Locke by considering the context of the troubled
Chartist times in which it was both written and set. She also briefly
discusses the novel's publication history, its reception by the critics,
and its representation of many of Kingsley's social and political views.
She regrets on literary grounds that Kingsley revised the Cambridge part
of the novel. Praising for the most part the characterization in the
novel, Cripps also lauds its graphic depictions.
Alton Locke
; Chartism
; Social
and Political Novel ; Social
and Political Views ; Cambridge University
; Characterization
in Novels .
Cunningham, Valentine. “Goodness and Goods:
Victorian Literature and Values for the Middle Class Reader,” Proceedings
of the British Academy Vol. 78 (1992): 109-27.
Cunningham considers the treatment in Victorian literature of the relationship
between the good and goods, between industrialism and its societal effects,
especially those on the poor. He declares that Kingsley was conflicted
by the two sides. On the one hand, Kingsley believed that a modernizing
England required industrialism. On the other, he was adamant that those
adversely affected by industry's foul effects had to be rescued.
Social
and Political Views ; Industrialism
.
Cunningham, Valentine. "Soiled Fairy: The
Water-Babie s in its Time," Essays in Criticism Vol. XXXV, No.
2 (April 1985): 121-48.
Cunningham analyzes many of the causes and issues Kingsley treats with heat
and hysteria in The Water-Babies declaring that they frequently coincide
with the age’s heatedness and hysterias for these causes and issues.
Cunningham also discusses The Water-Babies ’ various affinities to
other classic fairy-story motifs.
The Water-Babies
; Social
and Political Views ; Fairy-Story
Motifs ; Sanitation
; Cheap
Clothes and Nasty ; Glaucus;
Religion
.
Daumas, Phillippe. “Charles Kingsley's
Style in Alton Locke,” Les Langues Modernes Vol. 63 (1969):
169-75.
Daumas argues that due to Kingsley’s conflicting views on Chartism there
is a certain mystification in Alton Locke. Though the novel
seems to be an advocacy of Chartism and social reform, the reader when finished
understands that it is really an espousal of charity and Christianity.
“Contrary to what one had been led to think, Alton Locke is not a
tract in support of socialism, but a vindication of Kingsley’s own conception
of Christianity” (169).
Alton Locke
; Chartism
; Social
and Political Views ; Religion
.
Dawson, Carl. "Polemics: Charles Kingsley and
Alton Locke," in his Victorian Noon: English Literature in
1850 (Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press, 1979): 179-202.
Dawson provides an overview of Kingsley’s character, his social and religious
views, especially those on Roman Catholicism, and his involvement in and
his diverse attitudes towards socialism. He discusses Alton Locke
, “perhaps one of the oddest literary documents of nineteenth-century England”
(180), declaring that its recognition in modern times owes something to Kingsley’s
treatment being relevant to contemporary Marxist assessments of literature.
“Kingsley articulates the sense of waste in his protagonist’s life;
he equates Alton with the social upheavals of his age, setting him against
middle-class virtues and assumptions; and he creates in Alton a psychic battle
between social activism and pastoral escape”. In addition, “
Alton Locke could figure in the survey that Georg Lukács, makes
of the middling hero in nineteenth-century historical fiction” (201).
Overview
; Social
and Political Views ; Religion
; Catholicism
; Alton
Locke ; Yeast.
Dobrzycka, Irena. The Conditions of Living
of the Working Class in the Social Novels of Charles Kingsley (Poznan:
Panstwowe Wydawnictwo Naukowe, 1955).
In her treatment of Kingsley’s social and political views, especially as
presented in such novels as Yeast and Two Years Ago , Dobrzycka
focuses on what she perceives as Kingsley’s reactionary bourgeois ideology.
Still, despite his feudalistic views, Dobrzycka praises the realistic portrayal
by this “bard of imperialism”of the living conditions of the proletariat
in these novels. She also lauds his vehement criticism of agrarian misery
and his advocacy of sanitary reform.
Social
and Political Views ; Working-Class
life, Depiction of ; Yeast;
Two Years
Ago ; Sanitation.
Dottin, Françoise. “Chartism and
Christian Socialism in Alton Locke,” Politics in Literature in
the Nineteenth Century (Lille: Centre d'Etudes Victoriennes, U. de Lille,
1974): 31-59.
Dottin discusses Kingsley's social and political views as represented in
Alton Locke, especially those relating to Chartism and Christian
Socialism, as well as his own practical endeavors in these areas. She concludes
that while Kingsley is somewhat difficult to categorize, he is "neither a
revolutionary nor a fawning aristocrat", and that he is best described by
the two words Christian and socialist (54).
Alton Locke
; Chartism
; Christian
Socialism ; Social
and Political Views ; Social and
Political Novel .
Edwards, David Lawrence. Leaders of
the Church of England, 1828-1944 (London; New York: Oxford University
Press, 1971).
Edwards declares that Kingsley’s courage in writing his manifesto on 10 April,
1848 at the time of the Chartist upheaval has been exaggerated. Many
other preachers and religious journalists sympathized with the social and
political sentiments of Kingsley, Maurice, et al. However, Kingsley
was indeed courageous in going further than merely sympathizing with the demands
of the workers. He actually worked alongside them and “it was this
that in the 1850s brought on Kingsley, and on Maurice, the wrath of the religious
Tories of the Record and the Quarterly Review – and of secularists
such as Karl Marx who feared competition from the Christian Socialists’ ‘holy
water’” (136).
Social
and Political Views ; Chartism
.
Faber, Richard. Proper Stations: Class
in Victorian Fiction (London: Faber and Faber, 1971).
Faber discusses Kingsley’s views on class relations focusing in particular
on the novels Yeast and Alton Locke. He also pays especial
attention to a comparison and contrast of these views with those of Disraeli.
Because of his belief in a Christian Brotherhood, Kingsley was more genuinely
democratic than Disraeli. He also had less interest than Disraeli in
the place of old blood and family. Both men, however, conscious of
social problems pervading the working classes, wished to improve the condition
of the people through such intervention as better sanitation, increased church
action, and greater involvement of the upper classes. Still, contends
Faber, both men, despite some radical sympathies, were essentially Conservatives,
Kingsley becoming more conservative as he aged. Nevertheless, Kingsley,
who wished that upper class qualities be more widely disseminated among all
classes, was not rigid in his opinions on class, mainly due to his notion
of a Christian Brotherhood. “The ideal of Christian Brotherhood may
have encouraged some illusions about existing, or impending, class relations;
but it saved Kingsley from the sense of caste that oppressed so many of his
contemporaries” (96).
Social
and Political Views ; Disraeli
; Yeast
; Alton
Locke .
Fichter, Joseph H., S. J. “The Socialism
of a Protestant: Charles Kingsley (1819-1875)” in his Roots of Change
(New York: Appleton-Century, 1939): 134-156.
Fichter reviews Kingsley’s life and principal works focusing on his social
and political thought. He is balanced in his assessment, pointing out
a number of Kingsley’s faults, prejudices, and illogicalities in addition
to his good qualities. With respect to Kingsley’s changing views and
specifically to his title of Christian Socialist, Fichter declares that “he
was no more thoroughgoing Socialist than he was thoroughgoing Christian”
(135). Fichter briefly reviews Kingsley’s condition of England novels
declaring Alton Locke to be “a tremendously effective book” (151)
and the autobiographical Yeast to be badly marred by Kingsley’s intense
anti-Catholic bigotry. Fichter concludes that “the work of Charles
Kingsley was on the whole a genuine contribution to the improvement of man’s
relation with man. His mistakes were the mistakes of every demagogue
to tread the earth, but the hand he had in rousing social interest in English
problems more than made up for them” (156).
Overview
; Christian
Socialism ; Social
and Political Views ; Catholicism
; Alton
Locke ; Yeast
.
Findlay, Isobel M. "Charles Kingsley,"
in Dictionary of Literary Biography, Volume 190: British Reform
Writers, 1832-1914. Edited by Gary Kelly and Edd Applegate (Detroit:
Gale, 1998): 145-159.
Findlay provides a bibliography of Kingsley’s own works, a short list of
further secondary readings, an account of his life and writings with particular
emphasis on his social and political views as expressed in his reformist
works. “The personal success that Charles Kingsley enjoyed within the
Church and other established social institutions throughout his life did
not prevent him from making important contributions to the cause of reform
in England. Although he has been often dismissed as a mere popularizer
of the thinking of others, especially of Maurice, Kingsley achieved much
though his parochial duties and his activities involving political organization,
print culture, and education. If he did not resolve contradictions
at the heart of reform or reconstruct hierarchic notions of the healthy and
unified social body, the power and particularity of his writing and public
oratory nevertheless generated significant social change” (157).
Overview
; Social
and Political Views ; Sanitation
; Racial
Prejudices .
Fitzpatrick, Tony. “The Trisected Society: Social Welfare in
Early Victorian Fiction.” Partial Answers: Journal of Literature and the
History of Ideas 3, no. 2 (June 2005): 23-47.
This article examines how developments in early Victorian society and welfare
were represented in certain novels by Dickens, Disraeli, Gaskell, and Kingsley.
Fitzpatrick gathers from these novels a sociological and welfare-related discourse
that challenged certain aspects of classical political economics. He infers
that the books specify that proper reform depends more on a new set of ethical
principles that mirror the increasing interdependencies among individuals
than on major institutional changes. In Yeast Kingsley contends that
though social inequalities might lead to revolution, class politics are invariably
subordinate to Christianity. For Kingsley socialist solutions to society’s
ills, in the words of Fitzpatrick, “are as potentially tyrannous as a competitive
economy unless anchored firmly in an ethos of Christian community and fellowship”
(35).
Social
and Political Views.
Goldberg, F. S. “Kingsley and the Social
Problems of His Day,” The Westminster Review Vol. 167 (Jan. 1907):
41-49.
Goldberg provides a rathernaïveaccount of Kingsley’s work on behalf of
the poor and working classes and considers his views on social problems as
expressed in his novels. Though Kingsley believed that all men are
equal in the eyes of God, he was not a socialist. Rather, while their
social conditions must be alleviated, it was right that the working classes
should be governed by the upper classes.
Social
and Political Views ; Yeast ; Two Years Ago .
Gottlieb, Evan M. "Charles Kingsley, the Romantic
Legacy, and the Unmaking of the Working-Class Intellectual," Victorian
Literature and Culture (VLC) Vol 29, No. 1 (2001): 51-65.
Gottlieb provides an interpretation of Alton Locke that is dissimilar
to many other treatments of the industrial novel in general and Kinglsey's
novel in particular. He argues that Alton Locke and the representation
of the working-class poet are "safely apolitical" and in fact serve the interests
of the middle classes. The prevailing views of the narrator and novel
succeed, in fact, in espousing middle-class values more than the concerns
of the working classes. "The ideological work of Alton Locke
is to reassure its middle-class readers that it is not possible for a working-class
person to be an intellectual and remain loyal to his class" (63). The
novel, in short, reassures middle-class readers who may be fearful of a workers'
revolution.
Alton Locke
; Social
and Political Views ; Social and
Political Novel ; Romantic
Poets ; Political
thought, Influences on his .
Graziano, Anne. “The Death of the Working-Class
Hero in Mary Barton and Alton Locke,” JNT: Journal of Narrative
Theory Vol. 29, No. 2 (Spring 1999): 135-57.
Graziano discusses the status and especially the death of John Barton and
Alton Locke in the novels of Gaskell and Kingsley. On the one hand,
it may appear that the authors’ aversion to extreme working class radicalism
have led them to kill off their heroes out of sympathy to higher class loyalties.
However, Graziano argues that a close examination of the structure of the
novels reveals a more complicated reason for the demise of Barton and Locke
than the authors’ political conservatism. “. . . it is not a turn
away from a positive representational status so much as a development
of early implications and contradictions that accounts for the heroes’ ‘fall’”
(136-7). The heroes’ failure and deaths “are enacted through
the constraining opportunities and conventions of the genre. And thus
the politics of the moment cannot adequately explain why Gaskell and Kingsley
begin with potentially viable heroes and end with corpses” (151).
Alton Locke
; Gaskell
(Mary Barton) ; Characterization
in Novels ; Social
and Political Views .
Harrison, Frederic. “Charles Kingsley.” 157-161
in De Senectute: More Last Words. New York: Appleton, 1923.
Harrison, a younger contemporary of Kingsley, provides
a short tribute on the centenary of Kingsley’s birth stressing his work as
a social pioneer, especially in the political sphere.
Social
and Political Views.
Hartley, Allan John. The
Novels of Charles Kingsley: A Christian Social Interpretation (Folkestone:
The Hour-Glass Press, 1977).
Hartley in this book-length study interprets Kingsley's
novels in the light of the influence of the Christian Social Movement. He
contends that Kingsley is unusual in using novels to set forth the message
of one whom he, together with many others, viewed as the age's greatest prophet,
F. D. Maurice. "The value of Kingsley's novels ultimately lies less in their
advocacy of liberality and reform, than in their insistent justification
of both on the basis of Christian humanism. Kingsley's inspiration
sprang from Maurice whose reading of the Bible had shown his disciple the
meaning, both of Christianity and of history, and the novels proclaim that
social improvement had necessarily to proceed within the existing framework
of society, which for Kingsley meant a Christian dispensation based on Commandments
engraven on tablets of stone and interpreted by sacrificial love. A
minor prophet proclaiming a minor one, Kingsley thus added a new dimension
to the novel" (169).
Christian
Socialism ; Maurice ;
Religion
; Social
and Political Views ; Novels ;
Yeast
; Alton
Locke ; Hypatia ;
Westward
Ho! ; Two Years
Ago ; Hereward
the Wake .
Hawley, John C., S. J.
“Baptizing the Victorian Epimetheus,” Science et Esprit Vol.
XLIII, No. 3 (1991): 349-354.
Kingsley, declares Hawley, was unusual among Victorian clerics in being an
explicit advocate of technology. However, he was also very aware of
the grave social problems, especially among the working classes, brought about
by technology. Still his main criticism was directed at the spirit
of competition bred by the industrial age. Kingsley had “a complex
response to technology. He never portrayed the pursuit of technology
as a meaningful life in itself; he did, however, recognize its potential
for liberating men and women to engage in such a quest” (354).
Technology
; Science
; Social
and Political Views ; Religion
.
Hawley, John C., S.J. “Responses to Charles
Kingsley's Attack on Political Economy,” Victorian Periodicals Review
Vol. XIX, No. 4 (Winter 1986): 131-137.
Hawley discusses the reaction Kingsley and his political and social views
received from the contemporary periodicals with particular attention to the
responses during the Parson Lot and the Christian Socialist period.
Reception of
Kingsley's Works ; Christian
Socialism ; Social
and Political Views .
Hicks, Granville. “Literature and Revolution,”
The English Journal Vol. XXIV, No. 3 (March 1935): 219-239.
Hicks observes that “Kingsley made Alton Locke a plea for obedience
to the church and the crown, attacking the ruthless business men, it is true,
but opposing as well Chartist aspirations to working class independence” (228-9).
Social
and Political Views ; Alton Locke
; Capitalism
.
Hope, Norman V. “The Issue Between Newman and
Kingsley: A Reconciliation and a Rejoinder,” Theology Today (6 April,
1949): 77-90.
Hope contends that while Kingsley held that the world is good because God
made it, he was far from being an apologist for all of mid-Victorian civilization.
Rather, he was well aware of the social and economic inequities rampant in
society. Nor was he complacent about how the contemporary Christian religion
was sometimes manifest in society. Hope also observes that it may be thought
“that Kingsley was nearer the mind of Jesus Christ than Newman, who appears
to have had no social conscience whatever.”
Social
and Political Views ; Newman
Controversy ; Religion.
Horsman, Reginald. “Origins of Racial Anglo-Saxonism
in Great Britain Before 1850,” Journal of the History of Ideas Vol
XXXVII, No. 3 (July-September 1976): 387-410.
Discusses Kingsley’s frequent espousal of the Teutons and their society and
his belief that they regenerated a degenerate Europe at the close of the
Roman Empire. He also mentions the racial prejudices of Kingsley, admirer
and defender of Rajah Brooke, and his view that some races were better off
dead. Kingsley was sanguine that the Anglo-Saxons were spreading Teutonic
virtues throughout the world and in so doing were enlarging the kingdom of
God. “The reign of world peace, order, and morality was to be established
by the Anglo-Saxon-Teutonic Christians, and if necessary it was to be founded
on the bodies of inferior races” (410).
Social
and Political Views ; Racial
prejudices ; Teutons ;
Anglo-Saxons
.
Houghton, Walter E. The Victorian Frame of
Mind 1830-1870 (New Haven: Published for Wellesley College by Yale University
Press, 1957)
Houghton makes frequent reference to some of Kingsley’s most prominent views
and attitudes. These include, among others, his admiration of industrial progress,
his anti-intellectualism, his dogmatism and rigidity, his worship of force,
his doubt and ennui, his views on heroes and heroic legend, on Muscular Christianity,
on nationalism, on the therapy of duty and work, on women, love, and the
home.
Social
and Political Views .
Jewitt, Arthur Russell. “Charles Kingsley:
An Appreciation,” Dalhousie Review Vol. 4 (July 1924): 193-202.
Jewitt provides a short general overview of Kingsley’s life and works.
He stresses what posterity owes to Kingsley’s endeavors in such areas as sanitation
and the franchise and to his influence in the enactment of factory acts,
workmen’s compensation acts, better poor laws, and the right to form trade
unions. However, Jewitt offers little deep analysis and less negative
criticism. His treatment is gushing and ornate as in “Charles Kingsley
enriched English literature by the originality and imagination of his genius,
quickened and enlivened public opinion by his life of ideal behaviour and
resonant golden deeds, leaving the world better than he found it, going to
his reward recognized, revered, and loved, a ‘gallant knight-errant of God’”
(202)
Overview
; Social
and Political Views .
Jones, Tod E. “Matthew Arnold's 'Philistinism'
and Charles Kingsley,” Victorian Newsletter No. 94 (Fall 1998):
1-10.
After examining the various characteristics of Matthew Arnold’s “Philistine”,
Jones discusses Kingsley’s views on each of these characteristics and their
representation in English society. He then considers whether Kingsley
himself may justifiably be termed a “Philistine”. He concludes that
“Kingsley cannot be fairly regarded as a Philistine or even as an anti-intellectual.
This is not to say that he never displayed a characteristic that is typically
Philistine or that he never took an anti-intellectual position, but rather
it is to affirm that in Kingsley not one of the attributes of Philistinism
was prevalent” (9).
Philistinism
; Arnold,
Matthew ; Social
and Political Views ; Christian
Socialism .
Karl, Frederick R. An Age of Fiction:
The Nineteenth Century British Novel (New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux,
1964): 333-337.
In his treatment of Alton Locke Karl focuses on Kingsley’s social and
political views. Locke comes to believe that the Chartist goals, and
all political and social aims, can only be realized if linked to Christianity,
a belief earnestly held by Kingsley. However, Karl declares that Kingsley’s
argument turns into the “hollow rhetoric” of those who, fearing radical change,
advise prudence (335). The working classes must wait until others decide
it is time for their equality; they must not decide for themselves.
Because of what he considers the weakness of this thesis, Karl believes that
Alton Locke has a “flabby intellectual spine”. While the
novel is praised for some excellent scenes, the characters when they think
or act appear “platitudinous or intellectually shallow”. Karl’s conclusion
is that Kingsley, despite his compassion for the poor, “has not worn well,
but less for the old-fashioned nature of his narrative than for the intellectual
assumptions behind the novel” (336).
Alton Locke
; Social
and Political Views ; Religion
; Characterization
in Novels .
Kendall, Guy. Charles Kingsley and His
Ideas (London: Hutchinson, 1947).
This book-length treatment of Kingsley in addition to providing a biographical
account focuses in particular on his diverse views and ideas.
Overview
; Full Book
Treatment ; Social
and Political Views .
Kettle, Arnold. “The Early Victorian Social-Problem
Novel,” in Boris Ford (ed.) From Dickens to Hardy: A Guide to English Literature
Vol. 6. 2nd ed. (London: Cassell, 1966; this ed. first published
1963): 169-187.
Yeast, according to Kettle, is a combination of Mrs. Gaskell’s
naturalistic style and some of the more mystical and romantic aspects of Disraeli’s.
Though it is often categorized as a religious novel, its social rather than
its religious message was responsible for its contemporary objectionable
reputation. Kettle considers Alton Locke to be a better novel
than Yeast. He praises especially its treatment of social problems
and the horrendous work conditions suffered by the tailors in their sweat-shops.
Though it is clearly a “propaganda novel”, it is more than that. “
Alton Locke , for all its crudities and ‘dated’ quality, for all its
lack of the sort of art and intelligence one associates with those writers
conscious of ‘the novel as an art form', can still move us today” (184).
Social and
Political Novel ; Yeast ; Alton Locke
; Social
and Political Views .
Kijinski, John L. “Charles Kingsley's Yeast
: Brotherhood and the Condition of England,” VIJ: Victorians Institute
Journal Vol. 13 (1985): 97-109.
In his analysis of the novel Yeast Kijinski declares that the novel
despite its "bland didacticism" is very representative of the period, the
hungry forties. He argues that the novel also provides a strong insight
into a commonly held ideological stance of the time, namely that the growing
antipathy between the haves and the have-nots might be improved without force,
unions, redistribution of wealth if only all social classes acted sympathetically
and humanely in the true belief that everyone is a member of the same common
family.
Yeast ; Social and
Political Novel ; Social
and Political Views ; Catholicism
.
Kovacevic, Ivanka.
“Charles Kingsley's Imperialism and the Victorian Frame of Mind,” Filoloski
Pregled: Casopis Saveza Drustava za Strane Jezike I Knjizevnost SFRJ
Vol. 3-4 (1975): 55-72.
Kovacevic examines what
he considers to be Kingsley's manifest jingoism, racism, and imperialism,
declaring that his views on these topics were similar to those of Thomas Carlyle,
Max Muller, and J. A. Froude. He discusses briefly Kingsley's stance
on the Governor Eyre controversy, his xenophobia, his generally negative
opinion of the Spanish, the Irish, the Russians, the Indians, and others.
He declares that "Kingsley was a pure racist" who "taught that primitive
natives are mere animals" (68). Kingsley justified his imperialism
by his belief "that some are born to command and some to obey, and he extended
this belief to include nations and races as well. If those of 'noble
blood' have the right to comand, it follows that the Aryans should govern
inferior races" (55-56). Nevertheless, Kovacevic writes that Kingsley,
neither a theorist nor ideologist, should not bear too much responsibility
for the practical politics of the day. His racist and imperialist views
were those already being expounded by great numbers of the contemporary educated
English public.
Social
and Political Views ; Racial
Prejudices ; Imperialism
; Carlyle
; Muller, Max
; Froude
.
Lackey, Lionel. “Kingsley’s Hypatia
: Foes Ever New,” The Victorian Newsletter No. 87 (Spring 1995): 1-4.
Lackey examines the theme and structure of Hypatia. The novel’s
pejorative depiction of many aspects of the early Church was met with much
disfavor by many religiously conservative critics. Though the novel’s
ostensible thesis, according to Lackey, is that the early Church despite
its faults was better than the atheism it replaced, the true thesis is that
this Church’s bigotry, persecution, and violence are far from real Christianity.
Lackey ends by suggesting that a consideration of Kingsley’s views may still
be relevant in today’s complex civilization; he “poses an alternative to
the poles of a destructive Christianity and a soulless intellectualism” (4).
Hypatia;
Religion
; Social
and Political Views .
Lodge, David. “Introduction” to Charles Kingsley,
Alton Locke: Tailor and Poet, ed. Herbert Van Thal (London:
Cassell, 1967): vii-xviii.
In his introduction to Alton Locke, Lodge declares that while Kingsley
shows keen sympathy for the workers' conditions of employment and general
social plight, he is also critical of their general modes of reacting against
established authority. This was in keeping with the tenor of his ideology
for, as he aged, Kingsley abandoned his younger radical views and became
increasingly an establishment figure. Still, observes Lodge, Kingsley's effort
on behalf of the oppressed and deprived working poor, "of which Alton
Locke is an eloquent testimony, reflects most credit upon him, and leaves
him least vulnerable to the irony of a more sophisticated and more cynical
age than his own"
Alton Locke
; Christian
Socialism ; Social
and Political Views ; Chartism
.
Martin, Robert Bernard. The Dust of
Combat: A Life of Charles Kingsley (London: Faber and Faber, 1959).
A full book biography of Kingsley with excellent critical analyses of his
writings, practical works and his multifarious views and ideas. Contains
good illustrations.
Full Book Treatment
; Overview
; Social
and Political Views .
McCausland, Elizabeth D. “Dirty Little
Secrets: Realism and the Real in Victorian Industrial Novels,” The American
Journal of Semiotics Vol. 9, Nos. 2-3 (1992): 149-165.
McCausland discusses the role of sewage and its resultant illnesses in Alton
Locke. Sewage or excrement is also a metaphor for the waste produced
by the rich after they consume all the surplus value created by the toil
of the working classes. Sewage is “a sign of the suffering of the poor,
all that is left of them after the rich have devoured them; this suffering
is a result of the very system which claims to be creating a prosperous and
civilized England” (158).
Alton Locke
; Sewage ;
Social
and Political Views .
Mendilow, Jonathan. The Romantic Tradition
in British Political Thought (Totowa, New Jersey: Barnes & Noble,
1986).
Mendilow examines aspects of Kingsley’s political philosophy and discusses
some primary influences on its development: Carlyle, Shelley, Byron, Maurice,
Wordsworth, Southey, Burns, Owen. He also stresses Kingsley’s advocacy
of increased State involvement in a variety of societal spheres, for example
a special ministry for sanitation, broad-ranging laws regulating employer-employee
relations, an emigration scheme, more State involvement in education.
For Kingsley a paternal government “would orchestrate the different sections
of the people to produce the harmonious composition of a good society” (180).
Social
and Political Views ; Political
thought, Influences on his ; Carlyle ;
Maurice
; St. Elizabeth
of Hungary .
Murray, Robert H. "Kingsley and Christian Socialism"
in Studies in the English Social and Political Thinkers of the Nineteenth
Century Vol. I (Cambridge, U.K.: Heffer, 1929): 432-455.
After a brief analysis of the age's social and political context, especially
the Marxist background, Murray provides an overview of Kingsley's life and
works focusing in particular on his activities in the Christian Socialist
sphere.
Overview
; Maurice
; Social
and Political Views ; Christian
Socialism .
Peyrouton, N. C. “Charles Dickens and the
Christian Socialists. The Kingsley-Dickens Myth,” The Dickensian Vol.
58 (May 1962): 96-109.
Peyrouton examines the views and works of Kingsley and Dickens, especially
their social and political opinions. Though the two men agreed in part
on various aspects of society’s ills and their appropriate solutions, their
differences are as patent as their similarities. Peyrouton’s principal goal
in the article is to dismiss what he terms the Kingsley-Dickens Myth, namely
that Dickens through the influence of his novels established a Dickensian
school of which Kingsley became an ardent disciple; that Dickens “by igniting
Kingsley” helped the latter shape Christian Socialism; and that both men shared
many views and ideals (96).
Dickens ;
Christian
Socialism ; Social
and Political Views .
Pope-Hennessy, Una. Canon Charles Kingsley:
A Biography (New York, Macmillan, 1949).
A book-length biography.
Full Book Treatment
; Overview
; Social
and Political Views .
Rapple, Brendan. “The Motif of Water in
Charles Kingsley's The Water-Babies,” University of Mississippi
Studies in English Vol. XI-XII (1993-1995): 259-71.
Kingsley uses the motif of water in The Water-Babies to preach the
virtues of bathing and washing. Cleaning the body and the inculcation
of good sanitary habits is also an effective method of preventing disease.
In addition, washing with water, preferably cold water, helps the attainment
of moral rectitude. “However, the depiction of water as a cleansing
agent may also be viewed in an allegorical sense, namely as purifying morally
and spiritually both the individual Tom as well as the collective society.
Only after Tom's baptismal washing and consequent Christian rebirth does his
deeply felt wish ‘I must be clean, I must be clean’ begin to be truly satisfied.
Only after an analogous allegorical cleansing can any genuine regeneration
of England occur” (269).
The Water-Babies
; Water Motif
; Cleanliness
; Sanitation
; Religion
; Social
and Political Views .
Rauch, Alan. "The Tailor Transformed: Charles
Kingsley's Alton Locke" in his Useful Knowledge: The Victorians,
Morality, and 'The March of Intellect' (Durham, NC: Duke University Press,
2001): 164-189.
Rauch argues that Kingsley intended Alton Locke: Tailor and Poet ,
as its name suggests, to be a novel that harmonized quite disparate themes
and ideas. A staunch believer himself in the truths of religion and science
and their ultimate integration, he hoped that Alton Locke 's readers
would also accept their reconciliation and their worth when blended as a
pathway to absolute truth. However, Rauch considers that the novel failed
in this goal and that Kingsley's passionate attempt to reconcile religion
and science did not satisfy and did not convince. While Alton's own
"transformation" uses language taken from science and a purpose taken from
religion, neither are credible. "Because of its attempt to deal with all
controversies single-handedly, Alton Locke is , in fact, a polemic
and thus lacks the kind of intriguing suggestiveness that is so characteristic
of" novels by Jane Webb Loudon, Mary Shelley, and Charlotte Brontë that
succeed in linking "science with tradition without invoking religion itself"
(189).
Alton Locke
; Science ;
Religion
; Social
and Political Views ; Change,
Notion of .
Rauch, Alan. "The Tailor Transformed: Charles
Kingsley's Alton Locke and the Notion of Change," Studies in the
Novel Vol. 25, No. 2 (Summer 1993): 196-213.
Rauch considers Kingsley's belief that science and religion are compatible
and that the study of the former could only serve to support the teachings
of faith. Both are truth seeking activities. Kingsley also found
suggestive the parallels between transformations in the natural worlds and
transformations in the spiritual spheres. It is a parallel, declares Rauch,
that Kingsley adapted for the character of Alton in Alton Locke .
Kingsley is drawing on the progressive transformation of forms in the natural
world when he depicts the gradual change of Alton from an atheist and political
agitator to a Christian with a much moderated political reform agenda.
Science ;
Religion
; Change,
Notion of ; Darwin ;
Alton Locke
; Social
and Political Views .
Schilling, Bernard N.
“Kingsley,” in Human Dignity and the Great Victorians (New York: Columbia
University Press, 1946): 96-122.
Schilling examines Kingsley's work as a humanitarian and his efforts to dignify
the life of England's poor. "Kingsley achieved a working synthesis
between his religion and his radicalism; he made it seem as if he had to
be a humanitarian reformer because of the implications which he saw in religion,
not in spite of them" (96). Schilling discusses Kingsley's work on
behalf of sanitary reform and his campaign against the terrible conditions
of the sweated tailoring trade, stressing Kingsley's belief that many societal
problems had their underlying cause in laissez-faire capitalism. He
also considers Kingsley's advocacy of popular medical instruction and of
cooperative movements, his plans to make art, amusement, country life and
education more available to the public, and his staunch promotion of public
education. Though Kingsley became increasingly conservative and came
to embrace a form of feudalism as he aged, Schilling concludes that he "bore
the mark of all great humanitarians - the union of compassion, humaneness,
and optimism" (122).
Overview
; Sanitation
; Social
and Political Views ; Religion
; Education
; Christian
Socialism .
Semmel, Bernard. “The Issue of 'Race' in
the British Reaction to the Morant Bay Uprising of 1865,” Caribbean
Studies Vol. 2, No. 3 (October 1962): 3-15.
In his examination of the British reaction to the Governor Eyre controversy
in Jamaica, Semmel briefly discusses the support of Kingsley, a racial bigot,
for the Governor’s actions in brutally suppressing the black uprising.
Semmel also mentions the view of Kingsley, clearly influenced by Carlyle,
that blacks together with the Irish and the English working classes were congenitally
inferior and totally unsuited for the suffrage and self-government.
Eyre, Governor
; Social
and Political Views ; Racial
Prejudices .
Smith, Sheila, and Peter Denman. “Mid-Victorian
Novelists,” in Arthur Pollard (ed.) The Victorians (New York: Peter
Bedrick, 1987, c. 1970): 239-285.
Smith and Denman survey Kingsley’s novels. Yeast and Alton
Locke are his best. Yeast was the first novel devoted to
the notion that unsanitary conditions and disease existed in the countryside
as well as in the towns and cities. A “courageous” novel, it also provided
some indication “of the sexual squalor of the poor” (254, 253). Though
radical views are expressed in the novel, Smith and Denman declare that Kingsley
did not believe in democracy. “In his novels, as in Disraeli’s, the
independence of the lower orders must be achieved within the existing class-structure”
(255). Though Alton Locke has powerful scenes, its propaganda
takes precedence over the novel and its characters. Though Two Years Ago
has some good scenes, it is a “long-winded novel” (260). Smith and
Denman have little positive to say of Hypatia and Westward Ho!
, but state that The Water-Babies is Kingsley’s “most attractive book”
(260). “Charles Kingsley is a minor novelist, but in Yeast, Alton
Locke and Two Years Ago he helped to extend the novel’s subject
matter, and to make it more serious, more concerned with reality. He
saw God, Heaven and Hell in human terms. This was an asset to him as
a novelist, and gave substance to his novels” (261).
Novels ;
Yeast
; Alton
Locke ; Two Years
Ago ; Hypatia
; Westward
Ho! ; Social
and Political Views .
Thorp, Margaret Farrand. Charles Kingsley
1819-1875 (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1937).
A well-documented book-length biography and analysis of Kingsley's diverse
ideas and views. Contains a good bibliography of Kingsley's own writings.
Full Book Treatment
; Overview
; Social
and Political Views .
Vernon, Sally. “Trouble Up at t’Mill: The
Rise and Decline of the Factory Play in the 1830s and 1840s,” Victorian
Studies Vol. XX, No. 2 (Winter 1977): 117-139.
Vernon declares that Kingsley found objectionable the popular dramatists who
catered to working class tastes and abhorred, as he reveals in Alton Locke
, such popular theaters as the Victoria Theatre. However, many of these
playwrights in their melodramas wrote about such working class problems as
poverty, social discord, industrial conflict, appalling factory conditions,
themes dealt with by Kingsley himself in his novels. “The result during
the 1830s and 1840s was a small but significant body of plays dealing explicitly
with factory conditions, and in some cases delineating those conditions with
a stark realism that compares well with and complements the rather different
approach of the industrial novelists of the 1840s” (118).
Alton Locke
; Social
and Political Views ; Factory Play
.
Vulliamy, Colwyn E. "Charles Kingsley and
Christian Socialism," in Writers and Rebels: From the Fabian Biographical
Series, ed. by Michael Katanka (London: Knight, 1976; Totowa, N. J.:
Rowman and Littlefield, 1976), 159-191 (first published as a Fabian Tract
in 1914).
Vulliamy examines Kingsley’s views as a socialist as they developed and changed
throughout his life, paying particular attention to his connection with Chartism,
his work in sanitation, his socialist publications, and his activities in
the Christian Socialist movement. Vulliamy stresses that Kingsley the
socialist was extremely constitutional and on no account revolutionary.
In addition, he accepted the system of social classes as divinely ordained
and were not be changed. The pervasive social ills were to be blamed
on the individual not the class. He concludes that “Kingsley’s power
is to be found, not in the startling or original nature of his views, but
in his manly and uncompromising advocacy of those views, and in the example
of a most living and vigorous personality” (189).
Overview
; Social
and Political Views ; Chartism
; Christian
Socialism .
Ward, A. W. and A. R. Waller (eds.). The Cambridge
History of English Literature Vol. XIII, Part II (New York, Putnam’s
Sons, 1917): 392-410.
This is an overview of Kingsley's life and works with particular focus on
his novels. Kingsley's strong imagination and vivid descriptive style
are singled out for especial praise.
Overview
; Social
and Political Views ; Novels.
Wee, C. J. W.-L. "Christian Manliness and National
Identity: The Problematic Construction of a Racially 'Pure' Nation," in Hall,
Donald E. (ed.). Muscular Christianity: Embodying the Victorian
Age (Cambridge, U.K.: Cambridge University Press, 1994): 66-88.
Wee discusses how Kingsley used the innovative treatment of the relationship
of Christianity to race and cultural history in the novels Alton Locke
and Westward Ho! "in a process of national self-definition, through
what might be called 'cultural nationalism'." Wee argues that in doing so
"Kingsley also reveals the problems surrounding the construction of a pure
national-imperial identity based on racial and religious heritage, as he
attempted to propagate the potent but unstable image of a masculine, charismatic,
and authoritative Englishman who stands as a representative of a resolutely
Anglo-Saxon and Protestant nation-empire" (67).
Yeast;
Westward
Ho! ; Manliness
; Muscular
Christianity ; Imperialism
; Racial
Prejudices ; Social
and Political Views .
Williams, A. R. "Alton Locke by Charles
Kingsley (1850)," East London Papers Vol. 13 (Summer 1970): 36-40.
Williams counts Kingsley among those Victorian writers who sought to reveal
in their works society’s evils to indifferent and oblivious middle and upper
classes. In particular, Alton Locke is important for “historians
of London’s East End because it portrays vividly and, as far as one can tell,
reliably, the conditions of the sweated tailors of this district in the middle
of the nineteenth century” (37). Williams sees Kingsley as more than
just a depicter of societal problems. As a solution Kingsley advocated
three prongs of attack: the masses’ self-improvement through education, organization
in trade unions, and governmental reform.
Social and
Political Novel ; Alton Locke
; Social
and Political Views .
|